Gubisi

There were chats involving alleged companies from the EFF totaling 7, plus other companies from Nico to Victor totaling 7, and additional companies for land vehicles; Gubisi is not on any of these lists.

“in the second last chat, remember it is that list that allegedly came from the EFF and its seven companies... And then on 176, it is the one that you said was from Nico to Victor... And it is seven different companies, so in total 21. And Gubisi is not in any of those lists.”

Mandla Mgcina is the person receiving a large part of the proceeds of Gubisi's contracts with the City of Tshwane.

“Mandla Mgcina , the evidence will show , is the one who is receiving a large part of the proceeds of Gubis' contracts with the City of Tshwane”

Advocate Chaskalson asserts that Gubisi would not approach Deputy Chief Dhlamini if they wanted to rig the tender, but would go directly to the CFO.

“So Gubisi would not go to you if they wanted to rig a tender. They would go to the CFO, you are suggesting?”

Sergeant Nkosi's involvement in getting access to Gubisi documents such as invoices could benefit his brother's company, a competitor of Gubisi.

“... what I am dealing with is your suggestion that Sergeant Nkosi does not stand to benefit if you all ow him access to Gubisi documents ... that is how you get involved in assisting Ngaphesheya ...”

Extensive communications regarding TMPD1 and Gubisi invoicing between the witness and Deputy Chief Dhlamini occur through Sergeant Nkosi, with no direct WhatsApp messages between the witness and Deputy Chief Dhlamini.

“this mode of communication between yourself and Deputy Chief Dhlamini in relation to TMPD1 and in relation to the Gubisi issues about invoicing and termination, has the same hallmarks, that you are actually having very extensive communications, but there is no sign of them on either of your phones”

Mr M Nisi requested Deputy Chief Dhlamini's contact details to deal with TMPD1 and Gubisi invoicing matters more directly going forward.

“I requested for his contact details in order to deal with the matters moving forward, particularly on the accounts payables matter, as well as the termination letter”

There were no WhatsApp messages exchanged directly between Mr M Nisi and Deputy Chief Dhlamini relating to TMPD1 or Gubisi because Mr M Nisi did not have Deputy Chief Dhlamini's contact details.

“No, there are none because I did not have his contact details from the Gubisi invoices and I was not interested. And he would not send me any WhatsApp messages for TMPD1”

Extensive WhatsApp communications between Mr M Nisi and Deputy Chief Dhlamini, relating to TMPD1 and Gubisi, are routed only through Sergeant Nkosi.

“We see extensive WhatsApp messages in relation to TMPD1 and Gubis where you are communicating with the General, but they all got through Sergeant Nkosi”

Director Malatji states he would not allocate a large number of sites to one security company because it would create challenges for the City and other contracted providers.

“I would not allocate such a number to one security company because that itself would create a challenge, right, not only for me, but for the City. It would even create a challenge with other contracted service providers once they realize that Gubisi is allocated 37 sites at a go and some are not even located on one, hence I am saying I would not allocate such a large number to one security company.”