Murphy judgment

The SCA judgment (Murphy judgment) is scathing against the police and specifically against Generals Phiyega and Mkhwanazi for political interference in disciplinary processes, and it had been kept hidden for over 10 years.

“it is the High Court and it is a scathing judgment against, this is what is referred to as the Murphy judgment, and it is a scathing judgment against the police... And against, in particular, General Phiyega and General Mkhwanazi, against both of them. And this judgment has not seen the light of day for probably 10 years or more”

Mr O'Sullivan argues the failure to produce the Murphy judgment evidence and its concealment is more important than the judgment itself and it should have been part of the Commission's evidence.

“What is more important to the people of this country is that this has been kept hidden. It has been kept under wraps. It should have been part of the evidence”